Print, video, sounds

Aluminum cables and dead regulators

Ford management thought aluminum battery cables were cheaper. Meanwhile, hundreds of batteries were boiling out. pdf version
YouTube video of aluminum battery cables and bad regulators
When I worked at Ford Truck back in 1980, the company was run by finance weasels. These where the "Whiz Kids" like McNamara that came out of WWII with all the answers in simple numbers. At Ford the simple number was the cheaper number. All management amounted to picking the alternative that had the lowest cost.

The finance weasels hired a bunch of MBAs (masters in business administration) to be Product Planners. I thought engineers designed cars and trucks. How naive. In actuality the Ford cars and trucks were designed by finance people, MBAs, and stylists, none of them particularly technical.
Battery-cable
One day a product planner came down and asked why we didn't make the copper battery cables out of cheaper aluminum. He had found out aluminum was cheaper and he figured he might wangle a big bonus if he saved money.
Bottom of first columnmove down to the left

Aluminum-wiring
I knew aluminum battery cables were a bad idea because I knew how many fires aluminum wire caused in houses. It was considered a serious fire hazard even back in 1980. Today the code still allows aluminum house wiring, but electricians are instructed to use an anti-corrosive coating, and to to torque the terminal to a very specific tight tolerance.

To put a delicate marginal connection under the hood of a truck was a very sketchy proposition. An old-timer tipped me off to a report we could drag out every time the finance weasels suggested aluminum cables.

The report detailed how the terminations of aluminum cable would just not hold up under salt-spray reliability. There were also problems with cracking, since aluminum will fatigue and crack. It turns out they do use aluminum cable in light aircraft. The only way this works is to clad copper over the aluminum strands. That way the terminations are copper-to-copper.

Cladding is the way they make quarters out of very dissimilar metals. High nickel copper on the outside, pure copper in the middle. A professor told me the US Mint lays the three sheets together in a train flat car. Then they coat the top layer with explosives. They roll the train car into a cave and light the explosive on one edge. The explosion propagates, slapping the metal layers together.
move up a little to the right move down to the left
1980-Ford-Battery-cable-engine
The brutal engine compartment of the 1980 Ford pickup, aluminum cables would die. Note the wiper motor location discussed in a previous article about another Ford disaster.

Needless to say copper-clad aluminum cables are way more expensive than just plain copper. I sent the report to the Product Planner and never heard from him again.

1980-Ford-regulator
Meanwhile, around this same time we got a report of a whole bunch of trucks boiling out the battery. Then the alternator would go full-voltage and destroy all the lights and electronics in the truck. We soon discovered that the voltage regulators in the trucks were good, but they had lost ground.1980-Ford-regulator-fender
Here is a view of the fender where the voltage regulator mounted. The screws are where the regulator used to be.
move up a little to the right move down to the left
1980-Ford-Zinc-chromate-screw
The zinc-chromate screws used to mount the voltage regulator had to conduct electricity to ground the regulator. Without this ground, the regulator would go full-charge, boiling the battery out and burning out lights and radios.
1980-Ford-Black-phosphate.
It turns out there were identical black-phosphate screws, cheaper, but not electrically conductive. The assembly workers didn't know, so they used the black screws on a bunch of trucks. The "fix" was to make this a double inspection item. They would never standardize on the more expensive zinc chromate screw. One thing they didn't teach at college was how to keep 19 assembly plants churning out a million vehicles all built with the right parts and put together the right way.
move up a little to the right move down to the left

This post is in these categories:

border bar
Bottom of first column This is the end.